In the book, harry is back on the team and this time, ron is on it too. The two ways to discover this harry potter adventure are to either read the book or watch the movie. Discussion in harry potter book series started by goettingen, sep 9, 2003. For all the potterheads out there, this should prove to be a very short read but for all others, try and bear with me. Are you more of a harry potter book person or movie person. When it comes to harry, i love them both but there are a lot of details left out if you only see the movie. The harry potter franchise is a global phenomenon like few others.
Mar 21, 2014 harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off harry potter and the philosophers stone. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter. Rowling brought us the world of harry potter and endowed it with an impressive number of secrets. When comparing a book and a film, or something similar, the first thing one thinks about is obviously the plot. Comparison of harry potter and the sorcerers stone 1075 words 5 pages. Harry potter and the sorcerers stoneharry potter and cursed child text comparison essay in harry potter and the sorcerers stone by j. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. What are the differences and similarities between the harry. While its a nice emotional moment in the book, the films version makes more sense, logically speaking. Consequently, i realized many major differences and similarities in the reading and watching of harry potter.
Ive just finished reading chamber of secrets last night, which means it is time for another book to movie comparison. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections. I feel that the harry potter film series slightly messed up the final battle. Differences between the film and book versions of harry potter. Only uncle vernon attempts to stop him and he ends up falling from the window. In the 7th book, harry remembers this and realizes that the tiara is one of the horcruxes. The film begins in the evening of the day the masons visit, omitting dobby in the hedges and additional quarrels between harry and the dursleys. List of differences between the harry potter books and films. Harry potter book and movie comparison essay example. In the film, the trio pretend to be dementors by making.
Differences between the harry potter and the goblet. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets book vs movie add a difference. The grief of his father is clearly visible and audible shows the. Here are some, from harry potter and the sorcerers stone. The fact that harry likes ginny is subtly hinted at throughout a couple of the books, culminating in their relationship at the end of harry potter and the halfblood prince. Its been 11 years since the last book was released, seven years since the last movie hit theaters, and yet the ip is as strong. Did you know stephen colbert and jessica williams of the late show both received personal messages over twitter from j. It also chronicles the final battle between voldemort and harry. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone movie was very accurate to the book, but just didnt have important details like how harry potters eyes are green, the sorting hat didnt sort right and sing a song. This is essentially the same meaning as in the book, but simpler for audiences and quicker to show. A comparison of harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Compare contrast harry potter movie and book free essays.
Rowling similarities or well implemented scenes differences or badly implemented scenes meaning very well pictured by the director. Most of these differences include characters and scenes. Jun 26, 1997 harry potter and the philosophers stone is a fantasy novel written by british author j. The film was loved by fans, but deviated from the source material. Differences between harry potter and the chamber of secrets. Therefore, after finishing the book, i decided to have that experience again through watching the harry potter movie, written by j. In most cases, people would rather watch a movie than read a book.
However, in the film, it shows that ginny hides the diary, thus messing the whole thing up. The book begins in the morning of harry s birthday. Movie with all the new movies based on books or comics that are out, people wonder why hollywood keeps doing it. It was published in the united states as harry potter and the sorcerers stone by scholastic corporation in 1998. Rowling i think order of the phoenix might be my favourite harry potter book. The movie starts out with dumbledore on the dursleys. Apr 08, 2011 harry potter and the deathly hallows is the seventh and last book in the harry potter series.
While i didnt expect to be first in line for the final harry potter movie, at 11 p. In the films penultimate scene on the bridge, a lot is dealt with. A spinoff prequel series will consist of five films started with fantastic. No booktofilm adaptation is perfect, but for a long time, harry potter fans have felt that the philosophers stone was the closest to perfect that fandom got. Jul 12, 2014 the film s versions of draco, crabbe, and goyle operate on a much smaller scale than the book versions when it comes to tormenting harry. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone was the first of seven book series by j. It is about the adventure of an elevenyearold boy who grew up with his aunt and uncle and later discovers that he comes from a family of witches and wizards. Movie although the first movie in the harry potter franchise is very accurate, the book still has much more detail about everything. Harry potter and the goblet of firebookmovie comparison. They catch them by mistake after they apparate to their location. As i was already doing a reread of harry potter and the goblet of fire, i thought id use it as an excuse for a rewatch of the film adaptation like i needed one.
Whether because they split the final book in half or its just one of the easiest to translate to the screen, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is the movie most loyal to the book its. This movie was based off the bestselling novel, which was written in 1997 by j. Not in comparison to what else is going on in that central book. Its 2018over 10 years since the book release of harry potter and the. List of differences between the harry potter books and. What are the differences and similarities between the. Harry potter and the deathly hallows is the seventh and last book in the harry potter series. It doesnt take as much time and you get to the point a lot quicker.
Rowling, the famed boy who lived, harry potter learns of his magic herritage after hes taken to hogwarts a school of wizards and witches. Im really enjoying writing these so far and am loving really analysing the films and the books, so i hope you are too. Harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban is the third book, and it doesnt have a different british name. The films versions of draco, crabbe, and goyle operate on a much smaller scale than the book versions when it comes to tormenting harry. Vernon says they cared for harry since he was a baby, gave him their good food, and. What if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books. But compared to other major changes in the movies, this is one of the.
Nevertheless, both the movie and the book prove to be equally entertaining despite their differences. Jul 12, 2014 in all the potter movie excitement, its important to go back to our hp roots and compare the first real gamechanging harry potter book, harry potter and the goblet of fire, to its movie counterpart. Nov 20, 2016 timestamps below check out watchmojos new book, links below. Furthermore by presenting or displaying this content movieflame llc is not affiliated with these third parties, nor does not guarantee, approve. Which are better, the harry potter books or movies. In the movie fenir greyback is the leader of the snatchers. The harry potter series changed things in a way few imagined they would, be it c. Read more about harry potter and try our prisoner of azkaban book quiz or our prisoner of azkaban. Dec 14, 2017 what if the characters of harry potter looked like they did in the books. Yet at times, its difficult to truly compare the two. In the book, harry hides the halfblood princes potions book in a cupboard, and places the bust of a warlock on top of it, then adorns it with a wig and a tiara. The book describes an elaborate conversational battle between harry and voldemort, where harry reveals secrets and insights to voldemort and everyone like snape s true allegiance, elder wand s real owner, etc. The harry potter movies are overall faithful to the books, but there are differences that make no sense.
The goblet of fire is my absolute favourite of all the harry potter books and it had been a. Harry breaks up with ginny to protect her while he goes hunting for horcruxes, but of course they get back together. Asked in harry potter, philosophy and philosophers were can you find a philosophers stone. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies. Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. From my comparison of the book harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban and its movie adaptation, it is clear that there are a lot of similarities and differences between the two. Harry potter and the chamber of secrets that was not in. In all the pottermovie excitement, its important to go back to our hp roots and compare the first real gamechanging harry potter book, harry potter and. Harry potter and the philosophers stone was the first moviebook in the franchise. Rowling herself letting them know what hogwarts house they would be. Published in 2007, it follows harry, ron and hermiones quest to find the four remaining horcruxes, which are magical artifacts which hold pieces of voldemorts soul. Reading a book gives you so much more detail on the story or subject, and you can let your mind and imagination wander.
The entire dursley family attempt to keep harry from leaving with ron. In the film s penultimate scene on the bridge, a lot is dealt with. Differences between the harry potter and the goblet of. In the case of the harry potter books and the harry potter movies, the books definitely win the award for being better. Rowling and how the book compared to the movie summary overview.
Dec 23, 2019 from my comparison of the book harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban and its movie adaptation, it is clear that there are a lot of similarities and differences between the two. He is skimmed through in the film, compared to the book which. The book harry potter and the sorcerers stone differs from the movie harry potter and the sorcerers stone in many ways. However vernon does say that harry is not thankful.
Oct 16, 20 even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. In the film, who throws a rock through the window of hagrids cottage, hitting harry on the back of the head. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone ive never met a movie i like more than the book. Top 10 differences between the hp books and movies what did. May 10, 2004 harry potter and the sorcerers stone by. Harry, ron and hermione, the main trio, go to hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry for their sixth year. Added characters characters that dont appear in the book omitted characters characters that are in the book but dont appear in the film added. Goblet of fire opened better than any harry potter movie to date, so it.
It is the first novel in the harry potter series and rowlings debut novel, first published in 1997 by bloomsbury. Fans of the harry potter books who saw the movie adaptations found that there were a few plot points that the films either didn. I know what youre thinking harry potter and the sorcerers stone is the closest book to film translation youve ever seen. List of differences between the harry potter books and films harry. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies. Harry is able to show the audience that he doesnt want the elder wand for selfish reasons and make sure that no one else will use it. Even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. Below are a list of changes made to the stories of the harry potter books when. They arrive to capture harry and the others because of the taboo. Index the wizengamot differences between the film and book versions of harry potter i was thinking of separating the differences between the book and film versions into their own articles. Rowling, called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Harry potter movies ranked from worst to best collider.
The film series, by the nature of film and the necessities of making movies that could equally. In harry potter and the sorcerers stone, harry, an orphan, lives with the dursleys, his horrible aunt and. Dec 28, 2007 harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban book and movie differences were adding in differences as we find them, but if you notice that weve left something out, please email us at corrections. The way harry, ron, and hermione all meet is basically the same, except the dialogue is a little different. What plot points are missing in the harry potter movies that. Also, one of the biggest things that are different is the the book is called harry potter and the philosophers stone and the movie is called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Mar 24, 2020 grawp takes a lot of time particularly of harry and hermiones in order of the phoenix in a book that was already the longest in the harry potter series. Harry and ron are tied together in the cellar of malfoy manor.
If you were to read this book and watch the movie you would find many differences, but the main difference between the two is that the book gives more information to the reader than the movie gives to the. Harry potter and the goblet of fire bookmovie comparison author. Harry potter and the philosophers stone is a fantasy novel written by british author j. And in harry potter and the halfblood prince, at first glance, youll find its rather similar in both the book and the film. Ive only read deathly hallows and halfblood prince once and twice respectively though, so there might be bits ive forgotten in there which will sway my judgement over the next couple of days. Harry potter is a britishamerican film series based on the eponymous novels by author j. Rowlings beloved harry potter books kicked off their parallel journey as the kind of sustainable, decadelong film franchise that modern movie studios have come to covet above.
1382 141 235 963 1276 765 460 1075 42 481 1445 335 1330 560 1260 1529 470 823 1307 135 767 953 631 1413 809 665 1016 1163 1113 859 792 1300 1424 1455 1001 1431